WHY ONLINE REVIEWS CAN MAKE OR BREAK YOUR FRANCHISE LOCATION

Image Created By Canva

Even the strongest franchise brands live or die by what customers say about their local experiences. In today’s digital-first world, online reviews influence not only foot traffic and purchasing decisions but also your local SEO, brand credibility, and future franchisee interest. Whether you own a single unit or dozens, your online reputation is a real-time report card that reflects operational excellence or exposes weaknesses. This article explores why franchise owners must take online reviews seriously, how franchisors can support the effort, and what strategies deliver the highest return on trust, visibility, and customer loyalty.

WHY ONLINE REVIEWS CAN MAKE OR BREAK YOUR FRANCHISE LOCATION

By Gary Occhiogrosso – Founder, Franchise Growth Solutions

When most people hear the word franchise, they picture the big names, McDonald’s, Dunkin’, Subway, or Massage Envy. These names evoke images of consistency, brand recognition, and reliability. But what many franchise owners often forget is that while the brand itself may be national or even international, customers still think and behave locally. A franchise might be part of a nationwide chain, but every customer who walks through the door or places an online order is evaluating a single location. They’re not reviewing the corporate headquarters. They’re reviewing your specific franchise unit.

And today, they’re doing that loudly and publicly on Yelp, Google Reviews, TripAdvisor, Facebook, and a growing list of other platforms. In 2023, over 87 percent of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, including franchises, before making a purchasing decision. This number continues to rise as mobile-first search behavior becomes more prevalent.

In the digital era, where one review can amplify or destroy a location’s reputation, online reviews have evolved into one of the most influential factors in a franchisee’s success. A solid review strategy is no longer optional. It is a mission-critical aspect of running a franchise business.

Localized Perception in a National Framework

While a franchise benefits from national advertising, supply chain support, and operational systems, it operates within a localized lens in the eyes of the consumer. For example, a customer does not evaluate their visit to “Starbucks USA.” They evaluate the Starbucks on Main Street in Kansas City. The barista’s attitude, the cleanliness of the bathroom, the temperature of the latte, all of these micro experiences are assessed locally.

That assessment is then posted globally through online reviews. The entire brand benefits or suffers based on those customer perceptions. In this way, online reviews serve as the ultimate equalizer, highlighting both the franchisee’s execution and the brand’s commitment to customer experience across all locations.

Trust is the Currency of Digital Commerce

Consumers trust online reviews almost as much as they trust personal recommendations. According to BrightLocal’s 2023 Local Consumer Review Survey, 76 percent of consumers “always” or “regularly” read online reviews when browsing for local businesses, and 49 percent trust those reviews as much as a friend’s recommendation. That trust translates directly into dollars.

Positive online reviews are one of the strongest indicators of purchase behavior. For franchise businesses, this means a good online reputation can significantly increase foot traffic, digital orders, and repeat business. Negative reviews, on the other hand, can erode trust faster than any discount or promotional campaign can repair it.

How Reviews Impact Franchise Search Rankings

Google’s local search algorithm is heavily influenced by review volume, frequency, and rating. If your franchise location is not ranking high in local search results, it could be directly related to a lack of recent or positive reviews. Google My Business (GMB) listings with more than 50 reviews and a 4.5+ star average tend to outperform competitors in visibility and engagement.

This is vital because 92 percent of searchers select businesses from the first page of local search results. If your franchise location does not show up on that first page, you are effectively invisible to new customers. Optimizing for online reviews is as essential to local SEO as your website or business address.

Franchisees Must Take Ownership of Local Reputation

Many franchisees assume that the corporate brand will manage the online presence and reviews. This is a dangerous assumption. While franchisors may provide brand guidelines, social media templates, or reputation management tools, the day-to-day execution falls on the shoulders of the local operator.

Each franchisee must treat online reputation management as part of their standard operating procedures. This includes regularly monitoring review sites, responding promptly and professionally to feedback, and encouraging happy customers to share their positive experiences.

Franchisors should encourage this by training new franchisees on review strategies during onboarding and making review metrics a key performance indicator (KPI) in ongoing operations evaluations.

The Psychological Power of Social Proof

Social proof is one of the most powerful forces in marketing psychology. When customers see dozens or hundreds of people praising a franchise location, it reduces the mental friction of deciding where to spend their money. In many ways, reviews serve as digital word-of-mouth. They validate the customer’s choice before they ever walk through the door.

This is especially important for franchise businesses in competitive industries such as fitness, food service, wellness, and child enrichment, where consumers often face multiple choices in the same geographic area. A location with 100 glowing reviews and a 4.8-star rating will significantly outperform one with five reviews and a 3.9-star average, even if the services are identical.

How to Actively Encourage Positive Reviews

Franchise owners must implement a structured process for generating reviews. Relying on customers to leave feedback without a prompt results in sporadic and often skewed responses, typically only the very unhappy or very happy leave reviews on their own. To build a balanced online reputation, franchisees should:

1. Train staff to ask for reviews after a positive interaction.
2. Include review requests on printed receipts or digital invoices.
3. Send automated follow-up emails or text messages to recent customers with a review link.
4. Display signage in-store encouraging customers to leave a review on Google.
5. Respond to all reviews promptly, thanking positive reviewers and addressing concerns from negative ones.

When done ethically and consistently, these methods can significantly increase the volume of positive reviews and dilute the impact of occasional negative feedback.

How Negative Reviews Can Be an Opportunity

While it is tempting to fear or avoid negative reviews, they can actually be beneficial when handled correctly. Responding to a negative review with empathy, professionalism, and a solution can demonstrate that the franchise location takes customer service seriously. In fact, 45 percent of consumers are more likely to visit a business that publicly responds to negative feedback and attempts to resolve the issue.

This also presents an opportunity for the franchisor to evaluate whether systemic issues exist across multiple locations. If several franchisees report similar complaints, about training, product quality, or operations, it could indicate a larger issue that needs attention from the brand leadership team.

 

The Role of Franchisors in Online Review Strategy

Franchisors must empower franchisees with the tools, training, and frameworks to manage online reviews effectively. This may include:

• Setting up centralized platforms that aggregate reviews across locations.
• Offering templated responses that maintain brand tone and voice.
• Providing software that automatically prompts review requests after transactions.
• Hosting quarterly webinars or workshops focused on digital reputation.

Moreover, franchisors should regularly audit and review performance across the system. By identifying top-performing locations based on review data, they can extract best practices and share them across the network to uplift weaker performers.

Reviews Influence More Than Just Customers

A strong online reputation affects more than potential customers. It also influences prospective franchisees, employees, investors, and vendors. When researching whether to buy a franchise or work for a location, people inevitably turn to Google and Yelp to learn more about the local unit’s reputation. A location with dozens of glowing reviews signals that the operation is professional, reliable, and customer-focused, making it attractive to stakeholders across the board.

Case Study: Chick-fil-A and the Art of Review Management

Chick-fil-A is known for high customer satisfaction ratings, and much of that reputation is built on consistency in service and follow-through. Franchisees are trained from the beginning to monitor reviews, respond promptly, and take customer feedback seriously. Many locations use review management software integrated with their point-of-sale system to automatically send requests for feedback, allowing them to build a steady stream of positive reviews.

This strategy has contributed to Chick-fil-A regularly ranking at the top of the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) in the quick-service category. The takeaway for other franchise brands is that proactive management of customer reviews is a repeatable, scalable, and profitable discipline.

Ignoring Reviews is Risky Business

Some franchisees make the mistake of avoiding online reviews altogether, hoping that silence will avoid scrutiny. This is a false sense of security. Customers will talk about your business whether you are part of the conversation or not. Ignoring reviews creates a reputation vacuum, often filled with inaccurate, outdated, or harmful information.

Moreover, platforms like Google and Yelp rank active businesses higher in local search. A dormant online presence with no recent reviews will quickly fade from public view, pushing customers to choose more active competitors.

Final Thoughts: Online Reviews Are Your Franchise Report Card

In the franchise business, every unit must be managed like a standalone business. That means owning your reputation, managing customer interactions, and leveraging digital tools to showcase your strengths. Online reviews are not just a reflection of customer satisfaction. They are a real-time report card, influencing buying behavior, franchise valuation, and long-term profitability.

If you want your franchise to thrive, do not treat online reviews as an afterthought. Make them a core part of your operations. Engage with customers. Solve problems. Ask for feedback. Celebrate praise. Learn from criticism. Because while the brand may be national, the customer experience and reputation is always local.

Sources:

1. BrightLocal – Local Consumer Review Survey 2023
2. American Customer Satisfaction Index – Quick Service Restaurants 2023 Report
3. Search Engine Journal – Local SEO and Review Ranking Factors
4. Forbes – Online Reputation Management for Small Businesses
5. ReviewTrackers – Customer Feedback and Business Performance
6. Google Business Profile Help Center
7. Harvard Business Review – The Power of Online Reviews
8. Pew Research Center – Internet & Technology Usage Trends
9. Yelp Data Insights 2023
10. Entrepreneur – Franchise Trends and Localized Branding

© 2025 Gary Occhiogrosso. All Rights Reserved Worldwide.

 

 

LEARN MORE HERE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This article was researched, outlined and edited with the support of A.I.